BeautyRival – E.l.f. Beauty has built a reputation for creating marketing campaigns that spark attention and challenge conventions. From calling out gender disparity in leadership through its cheeky “So Many Dicks” sketch to enlisting actress Jennifer Coolidge for its first Super Bowl commercial, the brand has consistently pushed boundaries. Earlier this year, E.l.f. even sent astronaut Amanda Nguyen to space with its products, cementing its reputation as one of beauty’s most daring marketers.
Its latest campaign, launched on August 11, 2025, continues that tradition — but not without controversy. The ad, titled “E.l.f.ino & Schmarnes,” parodies the well-known Buffalo-based law firm Cellino & Barnes. Starring comedian Matt Rife and drag queen Heidi N Closet, the skit positioned them as lawyers defending clients from overpriced beauty products. True to E.l.f.’s style, the campaign leaned heavily on humor, parody, and pop culture references.
“Read More : Abercrombie & Fitch Partners with Dallas Cowboys in Multi-Year Deal”
While E.l.f. expected another hit following the success of its “Sunhinged” comedy special, not everyone received the campaign positively. Some critics argued the parody missed its mark, sparking debate about the use of humor in sensitive contexts.
Chief Marketing Officer Kory Marchisotto acknowledged the gap between intention and perception:
“There is a big gap between our intention and how this missed the mark for some people,” she told The Business of Beauty.
Marchisotto emphasized that the campaign aimed to entertain while highlighting the brand’s mission of affordability and inclusivity. However, she also admitted that not every message resonates the same way with every audience.
“Read More : Vaseline’s Viral Reinvention: From Healing Jelly to High Fashion”
Despite the mixed reactions, E.l.f.’s decision to continue using humor reflects a broader strategy. In a crowded beauty market, entertainment-driven storytelling helps brands stand out and remain culturally relevant. By collaborating with both comedians and drag performers, E.l.f. reinforces its inclusive stance and willingness to spotlight diverse voices.
Moreover, the campaign once again puts E.l.f. at the center of conversation — a place where the brand has thrived. Whether polarizing or celebrated, its ads rarely go unnoticed.
Industry watchers suggest E.l.f. will continue to push the boundaries of beauty advertising, balancing bold humor with social commentary. The company’s track record shows a commitment to campaigns that entertain, engage, and sometimes provoke, proving that risk-taking remains central to its identity.
For now, the “E.l.f.ino & Schmarnes” ad may have sparked mixed opinions, but it underscores a truth about E.l.f.: the brand is unafraid to take risks in pursuit of connection with its audience.
